The Pros and Cons of DIY SEO: Navigating the Path to Self-Optimisation

Welcome to the digital age, where a strong online presence is no longer a luxury, but a necessity for businesses of all sizes.

DIY SEO - The Brains
September 13, 2023
DIY SEO - The Brains10 mins to read
DIY SEO - The Brains

With consumers turning to search engines to find answers, products, and services, the spotlight on Search Engine Optimisation (SEO) has never been brighter. As entrepreneurs and business owners, you’re well aware that a well-optimised website can be the key to unlocking a treasure trove of organic traffic, potential customers, and growth opportunities – the question is, how do you go about creating one?

Enter the intriguing world of “DIY SEO”.

With the advent of user-friendly tools, online training resources, and the allure of cost savings, many businesses are now venturing into the realm of SEO without seeking professional guidance in the form of traditional marketers. That’s right, do-it-yourself SEO is gaining momentum as businesses strive to take the reins of their online destiny… but is this journey down the DIY SEO path paved with gold, or are there potholes waiting to trip you up?

In this comprehensive guide, we’ll unravel the intricacies of DIY SEO, laying out its pros and cons with all the transparency and insight you need. Whether you’re running a startup or looking to expand your digital footprint, understanding the potential benefits and pitfalls of DIY SEO is crucial to making informed decisions for your business’s online growth.

But before we dive into the depths of this dynamic landscape, let’s start by shedding light on the significance of SEO in today’s competitive digital ecosystem.

Understanding DIY SEO and Its Impact

Imagine being able to guide your business to the forefront of search engine results, attracting an influx of eager customers actively seeking what you offer… all without having to blow your cash. This is the promise of DIY SEO, a pathway where businesses roll up their sleeves and navigate the intricate world of search engines, keywords, and rankings, solo.

Let’s think about what this means in more detail:

The Essentials of Search Engine Optimisation

Before embarking on the journey of do-it-yourself SEO, it’s essential to grasp the fundamental principles that underpin successful search engine optimisation.

“At its core, SEO involves a series of strategies and techniques aimed at improving your website’s visibility on search engine results pages (SERPs). The goal is to enhance your website’s chances of ranking higher for specific keywords relevant to your business, thereby attracting more organic traffic and potential customers.”

James Speyer, SEO Lead at The Brains

It might help to imagine SEO as the crafting of a digital trail that leads search engine crawlers through your website’s content. These crawlers, or ‘search engine bots’ sent out by Google, index and evaluate your site’s pages based on various criteria such as:

  • Keyword relevance
  • Content quality
  • User experience

The better your site aligns with these (and other) criteria, the higher it’s likely to appear in search results, increasing its chances of being discovered by users searching for products or information you offer.

Learn more about SEO.

The Power of Targeted Keywords in SEO

Keywords are the building blocks of SEO, and understanding how to leverage them effectively is essential if you’re to undertake DIY SEO.

Keywords are the words or phrases that users type into search engines to find relevant information. Integrating the right keywords into your website’s content allows search engines to recognise the relevance of your site to user queries.

When selecting keywords, consider both their search volume and relevance to your business. High search volume keywords are frequently searched, which means they have the potential to drive substantial traffic to your site. However, high competition for these keywords might make it challenging to secure top rankings. On the other hand, long-tail keywords (more specific, usually longer phrases) may have lower search volume but can be highly relevant to your target audience, leading to higher conversion rates.

For example, if you’re running a business that sells sustainable gardening tools, ranking for a broad keyword like “gardening tools” could be challenging due to high competition. Instead, targeting long-tail keywords like “eco-friendly gardening tools” or “sustainable garden equipment” could yield more targeted and engaged traffic.

In the world of DIY SEO, effective keyword research is your compass. Tools like SEMrush, Google Keyword Planner, and Surfer SEO can provide invaluable insights into keyword search volume, competition, and related terms.

By building a comprehensive list of keywords that align with your business and its offerings, you’re equipping yourself with the foundation for a strong DIY SEO strategy.

DIY SEO - The Brains

Pros of Embarking on a DIY SEO Journey

The phrase “do-it-yourself” has taken on a new dimension with the rise of DIY SEO. Let’s uncover how embarking on this journey can empower you to make informed decisions, save on expenses, and gain a deeper understanding of your website’s performance.

Empowerment Through DIY: Taking Control of Your Strategy

Having a say in your website’s fate is a power like no other – and with DIY SEO, you’re always positioned in the driver’s seat. By understanding the intricacies of SEO, you gain the ability to mould your website’s visibility, rankings, and ultimately, its success. This empowerment allows you to pivot, experiment, and adapt your strategy in real-time, all while keeping your business’s unique goals and values at the forefront.

But, as we all know: with great power comes great responsibility – SEO is multifaceted, and managing everything at once (technical SEO, local SEO and link building, to name a few elements) will likely require careful planning and continuous monitoring if you’re to see real success!

Budget-Friendly Approach: Saving on SEO Costs

Navigating the digital realm can sometimes feel like a costly endeavour, with every click and view coming at a price. With this in mind, one of the most compelling advantages of DIY SEO is its cost-effectiveness.

By taking the reins of your SEO strategy, you sidestep the need for hefty agency fees. Instead, your investment is your time, which is a priceless resource that fuels your journey of discovery. With a wealth of online resources at your fingertips, the journey can seemingly become wildly affordable.

Not all agencies push lengthy contract tie-ins and inflexible fees – contact The Brains to discover how our marketing solutions can be tailored to your needs and budget!

In-Depth Understanding of Your Website’s Performance

Nobody knows your business better than you do – and when it comes to understanding your website’s performance, the depth of your insight can make all the difference.

DIY SEO immerses you in the intricate details of your website’s traffic, user behaviour, and conversion rates. This firsthand knowledge allows you to spot trends, identify opportunities, and address issues swiftly. As you uncover the inner workings of your site, you’ll be armed with the insights needed to make data-driven decisions that propel your business forward.

DIY SEO - The Brains

Cons and Challenges of DIY SEO

While the idea of taking the reins and steering your own SEO ship is undoubtedly appealing, it’s essential to acknowledge the flip side of the coin.

DIY SEO comes with its own set of challenges and potential pitfalls that businesses need to be aware of. In this section, we’ll shed light on the less glamorous aspects of the journey, exploring the time-intensive nature of DIY efforts and the potential pitfalls you might encounter.

Time-Intensive Nature: Balancing DIY Efforts with Business Needs

The realm of SEO is not a fleeting sprint; it’s a marathon that demands continuous attention and dedication. When taking on the role of your own SEO guru, one of the most significant challenges is the substantial time investment required. Crafting content, building internal links, conducting keyword research, and monitoring analytics can easily eat into your already busy schedule.

Balancing your DIY SEO efforts with the pressing demands of running a business can become a delicate juggling act. Your time is a valuable resource, and allocating it effectively between your core business responsibilities and SEO endeavours requires careful consideration.

Potential Pitfalls: Navigating Common DIY SEO Mistakes

In the intricate dance of SEO, even the most well-intentioned steps can sometimes lead to missteps. DIY SEO novices may find themselves traversing a minefield of potential pitfalls, from unintentional keyword stuffing to overlooking critical technical issues. Without the guidance of seasoned experts, these mistakes can hinder your progress and negatively impact your search engine rankings.

DIY SEO - The Brains

Making the Right Choice: DIY SEO or Professional Expertise?

DIY SEO demands commitment, learning, and a willingness to adapt – and the empowerment of controlling your strategy, the cost-effectiveness, and the deep insights into your website’s growth are undeniable draws. However, these benefits come hand in hand with the time-intensive nature of the journey and the potential pitfalls that can trip even the most determined of novice marketers.

So, before you decide how to approach SEO, we urge you to:

  • Consider your business goals and the resources at your disposal


  • Recognise that DIY SEO requires not only initial enthusiasm, but ongoing education to keep pace with the ever-evolving algorithms of search engines.

For those seeking guidance, strategy, and a team of seasoned experts, The Brains offers a range of services tailored to your business’s unique needs. Our expertise spans the landscape of digital marketing, including SEO, PPC, content creation, and more.

Whether you choose the path of DIY SEO or opt to collaborate with us, remember that your journey towards online success is a continuous evolution—one that can be navigated with careful consideration, dedication, and a thirst for learning.


How do I identify the right keywords for my website?

Keyword research is a crucial step in DIY SEO. Start by understanding your target audience and the phrases they use to search for your products or services. Use tools like Google Keyword Planner, SEMrush, or Ahrefs to identify relevant keywords with decent search volume and low competition. Consider both short-tail and long-tail keywords for a comprehensive approach.

Can I achieve the same results as professional SEO agencies?

While achieving the exact results of professional SEO agencies might require extensive experience, you can certainly make significant progress with DIY SEO. It’s essential to set realistic expectations and commit to ongoing learning and optimisation. If you find the DIY approach overwhelming, professional agencies like The Brains can provide specialised expertise to accelerate your results.

What are the essential tools for effective DIY SEO?

Several tools can aid your DIY SEO efforts, such as Google Search Console for insights into your site’s performance, Google Analytics for tracking user behaviour, and keyword research tools like SEMrush or Ahrefs. Additionally, on-page SEO tools like Surfer can help optimise your content, and backlink analysis tools can guide your link-building strategy.

How can I avoid common mistakes in DIY SEO?

Educate yourself about best practices through reputable SEO guides and resources. Perform regular audits to identify issues on your site, such as broken links, slow loading speeds, or duplicate content. Keep up with algorithm updates and trends to ensure your strategy remains effective.

Does DIY SEO require technical expertise?

While a basic understanding of SEO principles is beneficial, you don’t need to be a technical expert to embark on a DIY SEO journey. Many resources, guides, and tools are designed for users with varying levels of technical proficiency. Start with the basics and gradually delve into more advanced techniques as you gain confidence.

How long does it take to see results from DIY SEO efforts?

The timeline for seeing results from DIY SEO tactics can vary widely depending on factors like your website’s current state, competition, keyword difficulty, and the quality of your optimisation. Generally, SEO is a long-term strategy, and noticeable improvements can take several months. Consistency and patience are key.

What role do backlinks play in DIY SEO?

Backlinks are a crucial element in SEO, as they indicate the authority and credibility of your website. As such, DIY SEO efforts should include a focused approach to link building.

Seek opportunities for guest posting, collaborations, and sharing valuable content that naturally attracts backlinks. Quality backlinks can significantly impact your search engine rankings.

How can I stay updated with evolving SEO trends on my own?

Staying updated with SEO trends is essential for effective DIY SEO. Follow reputable SEO blogs, subscribe to industry newsletters, and participate in online communities or forums where experts share insights. We also recommend regularly checking Google’s official updates and announcements, and using tools like Google Search Console to monitor your site’s performance and stay informed about any issues.

Subscribe to our blog

Sign up to receive monthly updates on blog content from our Brainy marketing experts. We’ll be covering SEO shortcuts, advanced advertising tips and more!

Ready to schedule a free digital marketing consultation?